How to Make Black Frosting Without Dye

6 Comments on How to Make Black Frosting Without Dye

How to make black frosting without dye

When is the last time you went to a kid’s birthday party and ate cupcakes with black frosting (or is it icing?) and thought to yourself, “Wow, this is some really good frosting”?

Then you look around at all the other parents with their black teeth and stained fingers, and you know that everyone else is enjoying them as much as you are.


Black frosting is usually gross. It tastes bitter. It stains everything it touches. It makes parents call me and ask why their kid’s poop is weird colors (the joys of pediatric nursing). It is just AWFUL.

The solution?

Black Buttercream Frosting Without Dye

Every year my daughter makes cupcakes for my nephew’s birthday. This year he requested Darth Vader cupcakes with strawberry flavored cake. Right away she knew that she’d have to add some red food coloring to the cupcakes to keep them from being pink, but in order to stick with the Vader theme, she needed black frosting.

Knowing that black frosting is messy and disgusting, she set out to find a way to make it without the black dye. We are happy to report that she totally nailed it, and today I will be sharing the recipe with you, so you can do the same.

This is the best black frosting without food coloring you will find!

*Disclaimer- I am NOT a food blogger and after today, I know I never will be. Food bloggers do not get nearly enough credit for their photography skills. I wasn’t even the one baking, and I found it to be tedious. All that to say, there will be no beautiful food photos in the post, but the recipe is AMAZING*

You can tell from this picture that you will not have to worry about how to keep your black frosting from bleeding. This frosting will not bleed or stain fingers. It wiped right off my toddler.

It is possible to make natural black frosting!

First up, the ingredients:

black icing without dye


To frost 24 cupcakes you will need:

1 cup of softened salted butter (at room temp, never soften in the microwave)

1lb of powdered sugar

3/4 cup BLACK COCOA (and there you have it friends, the secret ingredient to rocking black icing (or is it frosting) with zero food coloring)

2-4 teaspoons of vanilla

1-2 tablespoons of milk

The black cocoa is the key ingredient here. I purchased mine from Amazon. If you purchase it through my link, I earn a small (I mean REALY small) commission at no extra cost to you.

black frosting no dye

black food dye tastes bitter

To make the frosting:

Mix the vanilla and butter together with a hand mixer

Slowly add the powdered sugar and cocoa while mixing

Add in the milk last, and mix until smooth and solid black

This is in direct sunlight, so you can see that the frosting is dark black.

That’s it! Mix it all up and you have black frosting with no dye. It tastes a lot like Oreos. My daughter doesn’t like frosting, but she enjoyed this recipe.

The Darth Vader Cupcakes were a huge hit! The strawberry cupcake turned out great. It is so delicious, and I think they are super cute.

5 from 1 vote

Black Buttercream Frosting Without Dye

A wonderful black frosting using black cocoa powder instead of food dye.

Course Dessert
Cuisine American
Keyword black frosting, dye free black icing, black icing, black frosting without food coloring, natural black frosting,
Prep Time 15 minutes
Cook Time 5 minutes
Total Time 20 minutes
Servings 24 cupcakes
Calories 200 kcal
Author Kenlee's Cupcakes


  • 1 cup salted butter
  • 1 lb powdered sugar
  • 3/4 cup black cocoa
  • 2-3 tsp vanilla
  • 1-2 tablespoons milk


  1. Mix butter and vanilla. 

  2. Add sugar and cocoa slowly while mixing.

  3. Add milk, and mix until smooth and solid black.

  4. Enjoy!


dye free black frosting

dye free black frosting




6 thoughts on “How to Make Black Frosting Without Dye

    1. Not at all! Obviously, it gets in your teeth when you are eating the cupcakes, but just like a dark chocolate bar, it goes away when you are done eating or rinse it down. No stained tongue, lips, or teeth. Thanks for commenting!

    1. Iā€™m honestly not sure. My eleven year old created this (ten at the time) and I posted it because I thought it was so good. šŸ˜‚ I just dream of having her baking skills.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *